John Deere Gator TH 6x4 vs. CLUB CAR CARRYALL 1500 4WD
A straight, spec-by-spec look for gator buyers across Ohio and Indiana. The numbers are only half the decision.
Is the John Deere Gator TH 6x4 right for you?
The Customer looking at the Gator TH 6x4 is usually someone who needs a dependable workhorse for a farm, large property, or commercial operation where hauling material day in and day out is the job. They want something that loads heavy, moves it reliably, and does not leave them stranded mid-task. The TH 6x4 carries up to 1,200 lb in the cargo box, which beats the Carryall 1500's standard 800 lb rating and even its HD suspension option at 1,050 lb. That is a real, meaningful advantage when you are moving feed, gravel, or equipment across a property regularly.
Yes, the Club Car pulls more on a trailer and carries more fuel, and its engine puts out a few more horsepower. We will not pretend otherwise. But the Gator's fully enclosed, oil-bath final drive is built for long-term durability in dirty, demanding conditions in a way that a forward/neutral/reverse final drive simply is not. When something does need attention, that is where Koenig's stores across Indiana and Ohio make a real difference: genuine John Deere parts on the shelf, trained technicians who know this machine, and a resale value that holds because the market knows and trusts the brand.
If you want to put the TH 6x4 up against your specific workload and see whether it fits, come talk with our team at your nearest Koenig location. We are glad to walk through it with you.
| Specification | John Deere Gator TH 6x4 | CLUB CAR CARRYALL 1500 4WD |
|---|---|---|
| Engine power | 11.6 kW 15.5 hp | 15 kW 20.1 hp |
| Cargo box dimensions | 1143 x 305 x 1320 mm 45 x 12 x 52 in. | 122 x 128 x 28 cm 48 x 49.8 x 10.9 in. |
| Cargo box capacity (weight) | 544 kg 1200 lb | Standard: 363 kg 800 lb HD suspension: 476 kg 1050 lb |
| Towing capacity | 635 kg 1400 lb | 907.2 kg 2000 lb |
| Front suspension | Independent spring-over-shock, single A-arm | Independent double A-arms with coil-over shocks |
| Rear suspension | Two high-floatation, low pressure tires (solid axles) | Semi-independent, four-link solid axle |
| Final drive | Fully enclosed; oil bath | Forward/neutral/reverse |
| Four wheel drive | All four rear wheels are driven, two front wheels are not driven | Yes |
| Fuel capacity | 18.9 L 5 U.S. gal. | 24.6 L 6.5 U.S. gal. |
See it at Koenig
Real pricing, financing, and a machine you can put to work this season.
Current Offers Apply for FinancingNot sure what fits?
We will walk your property and match the right machine to how you work.
Get a free Property Plan Find Your StoreThe spec sheet is only half the decision
People buy an experience and a partner they trust, not just a machine. With Koenig you also get:
- Performance Edge maintenance — scheduled service, multi-point inspections, genuine John Deere parts, priority scheduling; the 4-year plan adds a year of warranty.
- Parts and service ecosystem — genuine parts, warranty support, certified technicians, and online scheduling.
- Total cost of ownership — John Deere durability, resale value, and uptime often win over the life of the machine.
- A local partner across Ohio and Indiana — a team you can build a relationship around for the life of the equipment.